Jun 24th 2017

Piano clusters: How to frighten the old ladies of both sexes

by Michael Johnson

Michael Johnson is a music critic with particular interest in piano. 

Johnson worked as a reporter and editor in New York, Moscow, Paris and London over his journalism career. He covered European technology for Business Week for five years, and served nine years as chief editor of International Management magazine and was chief editor of the French technology weekly 01 Informatique. He also spent four years as Moscow correspondent of The Associated Press. He is the author of five books.

Michael Johnson is based in Bordeaux. Besides English and French he is also fluent in Russian.

You can order Michael Johnson's most recent book, a bilingual book, French and English, with drawings by Johnson:

“Portraitures and caricatures:  Conductors, Pianist, Composers”

 here.

I was flipping through my copy of Prokofiev’s Piano Sonata No. 6 recently and spotted his two “col pugno” markings. My memory took me back many years to the day I first encountered these violent directions. At the time, I didn’t know what to think. Measure 143 calls for the pianist to bang “with fist” on the four-note cluster chord. Prokofiev later said he wanted to “frighten the old ladies in the audience”.

It probably worked for him. In 1940, the year his sonata was published, the people of Moscow and Leningrad were already frightened. The Germans were everywhere, and they had guns. But now they are gone and we are accustomed to dissonance and percussive shocks from modern music, so these clusters are taken for granted.

Defined as simultaneous playing of at least three adjacent semitone notes, clusters turn up regularly in jazz and contemporary compositions so often as to attract little notice today.

It was not always thus. Charles Ives in 1915 amused himself with the aim of creating a stir in his Concord Sonata. The second movement, Hawthorne, makes innovative use of chord clusters, among other shocking techniques, to suggest “fantastical adventures into phantasmal realms”. Musicologist Joseph Machlis noted that “never before did piano music look like this”:


New York area pianist Jack Kohl reminds me that these clusters are too broad for the human hand, and so while studying the Concord himself, his father built a felt-padded strip of wood for him to depress black keys, then white keys, to achieve Ives’ effects. Some pianists just use the forearm.  Kohl notes that various composers have created “an entire subset of clustering” in which the width is wider than the hand.

Another subset fits the palm of the hand – a technique introduced by Jelly Roll Morton and Scott Joplin and widely applied by jazz pianists including the late Thelonius Monk.

Machlis continued with a technical explanation: “These (Concord) pianissimo chords are tone clusters designed to release the overtones and sympathetic vibrations of the piano strings… (The) floating columns of sounds are used as a source of sonic enchantment rather than as functional harmonic entities.”

What Machlis does not mention is that Ives intended to frighten “the old ladies of both sexes”. (He borrowed that wonderful metaphor from Charles Darwin, who had hoped for the same impact from his 1859 “On The Origin of Species”.)

Musicians today argue over the role of the cluster. Is it merely, as one musicologist opined, merely “an extra-harmonic clump of notes”? Obviously not. The avant-garde, going back to Henry Cowell and Leo Ornstein, used it to great effect. Bartok and John Cage understood its power. Indeed, the history of 20th century music shows how clusters progressively found their home.

Frederic Rzewski’s Cotton Mill Blues calls for right and left palm hammering on black and white keys alternatively to create powerful cotton mill mechanical effects. A roll-call of great contemporary composers loved the clusters. Pianist Ivan Ilic lists for me the principals as Sorabji, Messiaen, Louvier,  Xenakis, Ligeti, Stockhausen and the recently departed Finnish composer Rautavaara.

As Americans toyed with clusters, European composers were also experimenting with them. Isaac Albeniz tried them out in Iberia, and this success is thought to have inspired Gabriel Fauré to include his own clusters. In the 1930s, Henry Cowell’s student Lou Harrison worked clusters into his Prelude for Grandpiano.

And the ultimate experimenter, John Cage – another Cowell protégé – applied cluster chords in his work, notably in the 1941 composition “In the Name of the Holocaust”, titled as a nod to James Joyce’s “In the Name of the Holy Ghost”. Analysts detect chromatic, diatonic and pentatonic clusters in that monumental piece for Cage’s revolutionary prepared piano.

 

But it was Mauricio Kagel who noted the clusters are often used as “a kind of anti-harmony, a transition between sound and noise.” He may have been wrong about that but he rightly says that clusters “lend themselves to use in a percussive manner”.

And yet even Kagel seems limited in his appreciation. German composer Boris Bergmann tells me he likes to use clusters in his compositions, just fingered clusters, “not the fist … yet”. He finds that clusters can produce a harmonic quality, which functions like an acoustic kaleidoscope. “The change of a single note can alter the whole spectrum and emotional quality of the multichord”. He says he likes to use clusters to “contrast harmonically clear passages or as transitions from concrete to more abstract expression”.

Clusters are largely limited to instruments or groupings of instruments that can produce at least three notes simultaneously. After the piano, this leaves the human voice in choir mode. One of the most moving choral pieces that blends semitones into a giant tone cluster is R. Murray Schafer’s Epitaph for Moonlight. This clip, from the choir of American River College, Sacramento, California, includes an interesting introduction and a display of the original notation from the Schafer score. The music starts at 1:50.



Sometimes the cluster can lead a pianist to attack the keyboard rather than play it. While pianos are remarkably robust instruments, it doesn’t take a Franz Liszt to break it. Here an American musician best known for his mastery of the harp takes on a concert grand toe-to-toe. The piano loses. Note the cluster chord at 1:23.



To subscribe to Facts and Arts' weekly newsletter, please click here.

To follow Facts & Arts' Editor, Olli Raade, on Twitter, please click here.

 


This article is brought to you by the author who owns the copyright to the text.

Should you want to support the author’s creative work you can use the PayPal “Donate” button below.

Your donation is a transaction between you and the author. The proceeds go directly to the author’s PayPal account in full less PayPal’s commission.

Facts & Arts neither receives information about you, nor of your donation, nor does Facts & Arts receive a commission.

Facts & Arts does not pay the author, nor takes paid by the author, for the posting of the author's material on Facts & Arts. Facts & Arts finances its operations by selling advertising space.

 

 

Browse articles by author

More Music Reviews

Jul 9th 2020
EXTRACT: "In our chat by telephone, Paley spoke from his Paris apartment and asserted his belief that Rameau was “the greatest French composer ever. Pure genius and very special colors.” He acknowledges his extensive research into the period of Rameau’s life (1683-1764) in order to recreate the spirit of the time."
Jul 8th 2020
EXTRACT: "In A Fistful of Dollars (1964) and subsequent films, Morricone opted for an unprecedented fusion of archaic-sounding lines in the melody, reminiscent of medieval modal music. He intermixed this sound with contemporary pop touches (the Fender electric guitar), wordless choirs, unusual instruments (Jew’s harp, ocarinas, mariachi trumpets…) and ambient sounds (whip cracks, whistles, gunshot, coyote’s howls). He also infused scores with his trademark humour. This can be heard in the comedy western Il Mio Nome è Nessuno (My Name is Nobody, Tonino Valerii, 1973) where a toy trumpet toots bits of Wagner’s Ride of the Valkyries."
Jul 1st 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: Are you collaborating with living composers? Answer: Yes, Scott Wollschleger sends me unfinished new works every month. Keeril Makan is working on a piano concerto. Melaine Dalibert has dedicated several recent works to me. There are more names on the horizon. But these are the three where I feel I can have a big impact on their careers, and all three write music that I feel born to play. That combination of things is important to me."
Jun 1st 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: How do you see your musical mission today? Answer: My real passion in music is to resist popularity rankings and market forces. In my view, these currents impoverish our cultural richness........."
May 1st 2020
EXTRACT: Alessandro Deljavan: "I bought a former convent 40 kilometers from Pescara, in Villamagna. It's very important for me to breathe clean air and live as simply as possible. Life in a giant city full of cars and smog is hard for me to imagine. My perspective is always to live fully. My aspirations for the best musical experiences guides my decisions and over the past several years I have had the pleasure of meeting and working with some wonderful musicians—these experiences have brought me a sense of optimism for what might lie ahead.”
Apr 16th 2020
EXTRACT: "Federico Mompou, the reclusive Catalonian composer whose calm, spare piano writing is currently enjoying a rebirth, might well look askance at any effort to pull him forward into modern mode. Such was never his genre but that’s precisely what one of his ardent admirers, pianist Maria Canyigueral, proposed to do. The result is her intriguing new CD, Avant-guarding Mompou."
Mar 22nd 2020
EXTRACT: "In our interview, Prof. Réach says he cautions his students in Barcelona to approach the Variations with care, warning them “the path will be long and will require great patience”. He has personally overcome his fear of this “masterpiece of masterpieces”, having recorded them three times and performed them in about 15 countries a total of about 150 times."
Mar 13th 2020
EXTRACT: "The 88-key piano looks headed for a major transformation in the coming decades. The mechanism under the lid is based on a 130-year-old design and many specialists believe it is time to dispense with those delicate moving parts.  As innovative Australian piano builder Wayne Stuart says, “The piano has been crying out for a rethink for over a hundred years.” "
Mar 8th 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: You have a Paris background. What do you bring to Granados to ensure Spanish flavor? Delicacy? Momentum? Singing and dancing undertones? Rubato?........Answer: First, I am profoundly European........."
Feb 15th 2020
EXTRACT: "Question: You have said that you are plagued by doubts. Is this true?.........Answer: Of course I am plagued by doubts. This is part of the artist’s life. But I continue to work and perform. I have moments of depression but I try to transform these doubts into positives. Many artists have these doubts. Some don’t talk about it. But doubt is always there."
Jan 26th 2020
EXTRACT: "QUESTION: Wouldn’t young composers of today benefit from aligning themselves with a philosophical ethos in order to find their musical voice -- as opposed to trying merely to find their own voice by drawing on imagination or personal experience?.......... ANSWER: It’s an interesting question, but open to interpretation. My impulse is to answer yes. When young I did a tremendous amount of reading in the history of aesthetics, and as a result my sense of artist -- ethos, necessity, whatever -- is not limited to post-WWII influences. One result is that I’ve never had any patience for the late-20th-century idea that art is about “personal expression.” The ancient and more enduring view is that the artist expresses what is out there to be expressed. As T.S. Eliot admirably wrote, art is an escape from personality, not an expression of it. Likewise I’ve never warmed to the idea of “finding one’s voice,” which sounds to me too much like creating an instantly recognizable trademark style that will make your music easier to market commercially."
Jan 19th 2020
EXTRACT: "It has been a long journey I enjoy re-living as I take note this year of the great Ludwig van Beethoven’s 250th birthday. As a practicing music critic and journalist from American corn country, I call myself a hick hack but I experience meltdown at almost everything the great man wrote. How can one not love Beethoven?"
Jan 9th 2020
EXTRACT: "Judith Juaregui, based in Madrid but peripatetic in her concertizing around Europe, is gaining an international audience of admirers, boosted by the brilliant pianistic colors of her Debussy, Liszt, Falla, Chopin and Mompou in her fifth CD, “Pour le Tombeau de Claude Debussy”, just out. This album was recorded at a recital in Vienna last year, her first foray into live recording, and she is  rather pleased with the result, which, she says in our interview (below), captured a “moment of honesty”. She left everything in, including the vigorous applause from the audience."
Dec 11th 2019
EXTRACTS: "The young tousle-haired pianist from the distant Minnesota, Reed Tetzloff, is building a performance career in the U.S. and Europe by steering a course through rare repertoire that is both challenging and attractive for the listener........In our email question-and-answer discussion he explains his priorities as a musician and his attraction to a wide range of repertoire."
Dec 9th 2019
Extract: "Then the house lights came up and the rest of us rushed out, relieved that it was all over."
Nov 15th 2019
Extract: "Question: Mompou was modest, yet one of his famous comments is similar to Handel’s remark that he was writing down what God dictated. Mompou said he did not think up music, he simply transmitted it. Answer: The Mompou’s idea about God was interesting. God was a great force that also could destroy his own creation, like a child who in a moment of joy treads on an ant without noticing. Mompou explained that, in his case, the music was not coming from inside to outside, but the opposite way, from outside to the inside, with him being the intermediary of this flow, as a kind of medium. Mompou felt embarrassed to be called on stage after a performance of his music. He was convinced that if the work was really good, it was not entirely created by himself. 
Oct 27th 2019
Composer Kyle Gann’s new book ‘The Arithmetic of Listening’ analyzes microtonality and makes a plea for the music fraternity to open its ears to the new directions possible. After 22 years of teaching at Bard College in the eastern United States, Gann has become a guru or godfather of new music, and continues to produce captivating compositions, as in his new two-CD album ‘Hyperchromatica’. His latest book analyzes and explains tuning theory. In this interview he asserts that new music that gets the attention of publishers and producers today is mostly “derivative crap”. The golden age of “downtown” music from 1960 to 2000 assembled “a bunch of escapees from the twin hells of academia and corporate commercialism”.
Oct 21st 2019
EXTRACT: "A powerful new talent from Italy, Alessandro Deljavan, made his U.S. East Coast debut October 19, with a magnificent reading of the Brahms Piano concerto No. 2 under conductor Benjamin Zander and the Boston Philharmonic Orchestra."
Sep 18th 2019
EXTRACT: "This is some of Ilic’s best work. A California native of Serbian extraction, he is emerging now as a major player in a crowded field."
Sep 8th 2019
Extract: "Chopin’s two piano concertos are among the most frequently recorded of 19th century works, both for their melodic charm, their pulsing rhythms and their historical significance. Young Chopin wrote the piano part with exceptional verve, showing the way for future composers to let the piano burst free from its orchestral surroundings."