Jan 26th 2020

Kyle Gann interview : ‘No one knows what’s good in new music’

by Michael Johnson

Michael Johnson is a music critic with particular interest in piano. 

Johnson worked as a reporter and editor in New York, Moscow, Paris and London over his journalism career. He covered European technology for Business Week for five years, and served nine years as chief editor of International Management magazine and was chief editor of the French technology weekly 01 Informatique. He also spent four years as Moscow correspondent of The Associated Press. He is the author of five books.

Michael Johnson is based in Bordeaux. Besides English and French he is also fluent in Russian.

You can order Michael Johnson's most recent book, a bilingual book, French and English, with drawings by Johnson:

“Portraitures and caricatures:  Conductors, Pianist, Composers”



Composer Kyle Gann, in his new book ‘The Arithmetic of Listening’, makes a plea for the music fraternity to open its ears to the new directions possible. After 22 years of teaching, Gann has become a guru of new music. Although he modestly considers himself a “fringe figure”, he continues to produce ground-breaking compositions, as in his new two-CD album ‘Hyperchromatica’. As he has written, ”Give yourself some time to listen to the pieces over and over, and you’ll probably get used to them.”  In Part I of our interview, he asserts that most new music that gets the attention of publishers and producers today is derivative in nature, compared to the “golden age” contemporary composition in the U.S. from 1960 to 2000. As he put it in Part I, those composers consisted of “a bunch of escapees from the twin hells of academia and corporate commercialism”. (See Part 1 here )


In Part II, he analyzes his own place in the music world and questions public resistance to the unfamiliar. Musica-lovers are conservative in their tastes, he says. Why? “It’s a mystery”.


Our email dialogue follows:


MJ Kyle Glann
Kyle Gann by the interviewer Michael Johnson


Q. You once endorsed “ecumenical open-mindedness” toward new sound worlds. Do you see other musicians or music-lovers agreeing, and demonstrating real tolerance for newness?


A. Oh, open-mindedness as a virtue in itself is very popular at the moment, insofar as it means not discriminating against other musical genres. A tolerance for real newness is much rarer. The great tragedy is that, collectively, musicians long ago decided that no one knows what’s good in new music anyway.



Q.  We used to know good from bad. What happened along the way?

The main cause, I think, was the scholarly embrace of Schoenberg and his disciples, which disastrously shook people’s confidence in their own ears. The unfortunate upshot is that, if you do something new that’s so abstract or complicated that no one understands it, the musical elites tend to give it the benefit of the doubt. If you do something new and they can understand it, they dismiss it as “well, it’s not going to catch on.”


Q. What do you mean by catching on?


“Catching on” means success, and our musical elites critique musical trends the way op-ed writers review political races, not to judge anything on merit but to keep score of who’s winning. So there is a glib tolerance for a certain type of vague newness, but not toward anything clear-cut.


Q. Examples?


A. Take microtonality, minimalism, and pop influences. Microtonality “just doesn’t sound good” to people who haven’t taken the time to get used to it or seek out the best of it. Minimalism remains widely frowned upon in music composition programs, disdained on principle for its very popular success. Pop influences in new composed music are frowned upon even by younger composers who love pop music, which blows my mind.


Q. Except for smalI groups of fans, mostly trained musicians, I see less open-mindedness in the public. They seem to prefer visiting “the museum”. Why is this?


A. I think it’s the economy. People are scared and stretched thin, and they rein in their imaginations to survive. We do not have a sense now that “everything is possible,” nor that the unfamiliar will be safe. Society is contracting, and resources will have to flow back to everyone again before it will feel safe to expand. Many smart people have speculated as to why conservatism remains a stronger force in music than in art or literature. I have nothing to add to that conversation. It’s a mystery.


In this clip, he plays the daring “Neptune Night” from his album “Hyperchromatica”:



Q. Going back to Cowell and Cage, the rejection of the European music traditions has been a constant in the new music world. Surely you don’t hate Beethoven, Schubert, Brahms … do you? I know you are a Liszt admirer.


A. Almost every composer loves all that music, but it is tragic to live (as those composers didn’t) in a concert-going world in which 95 percent of the music made public is from the distant past. I’ve stolen as many devices from Beethoven, Bruckner, Schubert, and Liszt as any composer living, but I have no patience for concerts at which only that music is played. Mozart is wonderful, but I would far rather live in a new creative world analogous to his than live as a tourist endlessly visiting a preserved simulacrum of his world every day.



Q. Isn’t “beautiful music” a personal matter, a subjective term?


A. The subjectivity of beauty in music has been greatly overstated. Any music or art or literature, when it first appears, may find public resonance for a variety of subjective reasons. Eventually, though, the social reasons for that resonance will fade away, and under close collective scrutiny the quality of a piece will gradually become evident.


Q. Do you think it possible that one who idolizes Charles Ives the composer in fact admires the combination of biographical and musico-philosophical example set by Ives? 

A. No. The music is fantastic and limitlessly imaginative. The biography is not all that interesting and the philosophy not well defined. The music makes the biography interesting, not the other way around.


Q. You have studied Ives’ output and motiovations. Do you feel there is subtle evidence of Emersonian and/or Thoreauvian ideas in his musical output -- in the music itself ?

A. Sure, I suppose. Each of us is greatly imprinted by the atmosphere of new ideas that arises while we’re in our late teens and early twenties. When Ives was at Yale, Emerson was still championed as the great American thinker, and Thoreau was just being discovered. In order to be deeply impressed – as I believe Emerson wrote somewhere – I think we already have to have inside ourselves some inchoate tendency or idea that we respond to in (or read into) the literature, music, and so on that attracts us. The cloudiness and impressionism of Ives’s music and thought responded not only to them, but also to ideas that were “in the air” with William James, George Santayana, and others, even the Theosophists with their affinity for Scriabin. It was a time in which literal realism was being challenged by thoughts of a deeper spiritual perception.


Q. Speaking as a composer, you do not believe music comes out of thin air, does it?

A. I’m always acutely aware how much inspiration comes from the materials any composer is working with. You push notes, and they push back – you place a sound in your imagination, and when played it sounds like something you didn’t expect. Ives, for example, was in the first generation to encounter Helmholtz’s “On the Sensations of Tone”, and (like Debussy and others) he was becoming aware of the overtone series, both as spiritual metaphor and as a template for new approaches to harmony and rhythm. The experiences Ives had experimenting with new tone and rhythmic materials was well suited to merge with the new super-realism of late 19th-century philosophy and religion.


Q. Wouldn’t young composers of today benefit from aligning themselves with a philosophical ethos in order to find their musical voice -- as opposed to trying merely to find their own voice by drawing on imagination or personal experience?

A. It’s an interesting question, but open to interpretation. My impulse is to answer yes. When young I did a tremendous amount of reading in the history of aesthetics, and as a result my sense of artist -- ethos, necessity, whatever -- is not limited to post-WWII influences. One result is that I’ve never had any patience for the late-20th-century idea that art is about “personal expression.” The ancient and more enduring view is that the artist expresses what is out there to be expressed. As T.S. Eliot admirably wrote, art is an escape from personality, not an expression of it. Likewise I’ve never warmed to the idea of “finding one’s voice,” which sounds to me too much like creating an instantly recognizable trademark style that will make your music easier to market commercially.


Q. How does corporate control of the music business squeeze out creative work?  Won’t creative urges always find a way to break free?

A. The first question rather answers itself, doesn’t it? Since at least Kant, art has been defined as disinterested pleasure, and if you’re doing it with an eye to make money, that’s no longer disinterested. And the second question is again economic. Artists need resources, collaborative aid, and opportunities to do their work and make it public. Creative urges always break free, but if they are denied realization and access to a public forum, they are sometimes squelched at birth.


Q. Do your composer friends continue producing (in the Charles Ives tradition) in the belief that an audience is out there, we just have to find it or wait for it to catch up?


A. We have collectively abandoned, I think, the old belief that there’s some kind of Hegelian World Spirit that guides the course of cultural ideas, in favor of a more Marxist realization that economic powers can push a society in a particular cultural direction. That is, of course there’s an audience out there, for almost anything – if corporations put enough money behind it to expose it widely. In 1992 Nonesuch records made Gorecki’s then-seventeen-year-old “Symphony of Sorrowful Songs” famous by sending it out to a wide range of tastemakers and celebrities. I think it’s a mediocre piece, and that its appeal will dwindle, but I think that if Nonesuch wanted to pour the same amount of money into some of my pieces, or almost anyone’s works, a similar effect could be produced.


Q. How important is the rise of self-publishing of avant-garde music. Is this perhaps going to be our salvation?

The question now sounds old-fashioned. Now composers can handle the distribution of their music themselves, though with little money or distribution to aid them. The few composers who still publish with corporations have their music tied up by copyright and lose control over it, often getting no more than having it warehoused as a tax write-off. For music of the last forty years, if it’s not published I can usually find it, and if it is published I often can’t get my hands on it. The music publishing business has imploded and become irrelevant, if not indeed actively harmful.


Q. What is your relationship with the piano?  You have said you like almost anything written for the piano (so do I) yet you dropped it and stopped practicing some years ago. That must have left a huge void. Will you return to it one day?


A. No. I don’t have the discipline to sit there and work at it long enough to get good enough to enjoy it again. I do miss it, but I started typing instead, which became a more manageable substitute.


Q. Has composition replaced performance for you? It would seem so. You have written a lot of piano music, including transcriptions. Is this the focus of your activity now?


A. Writing words was what replaced performance. I’m not a performer-type personality, my brain slips up, forgets, and stutters. I do that in writing too, but no one can tell from the edited end result. I do write a lot of keyboard transcriptions, in order to thoroughly understand some pieces I love. I recently learned more about composing from making a keyboard reduction of Copland’s Third Symphony than I had from any other activity in years. These days I write for mechanical pianos primarily because I can’t get anyone to perform my music.


Q. Where do you see the future of your music going? Do you see it gaining more and more recognition?

In the last few years my music has completely fallen off the map. Except for a small frisson that “Hyperchromatica” seems to have created among young microtonalists, interest in my music has settled around zero. There are many plausible reasons: I’m a white male in an identity-politics era, my approach to microtonality is too baffling, everyone ignores composers who haven’t become brand names by a certain age, I live in the boondocks, I’m not a “people person.” For the first time since the 1980s I have just gone 14 months without composing anything. At the moment I can’t stand the thought of putting energy into something no one will perform. Perhaps this will change again.


Q. Do you wonder how you will be remembered when your time comes? Do you care?

Emphatically yes to all three. Matthew Arnold argued, in “Culture and Anarchy” I think, that great art requires not only the artist capable of it but the right cultural moment in which to realize and receive it. I’ve learned by age 64 that an artist’s most copious and exemplary accomplishments can effectively add up to nothing if the society of the time is not receptive to them. Henry Thoreau was denigrated and ignored for thirty years after his death; in the 1890s thinkers arose who were ready for what he had had to say. I could name quite a number of composers from the past whose music I think has been unjustifiably excluded from “the canon.” I can’t doubt that I have achieved something worthwhile, and I’m tired of speculating why my ideas have achieved such spotty resonance.


Q.  Yet you are a household name among switched-on musicians !

I could do worse than to end up like Erik Satie, with a wide following but eternally considered a fringe figure. During my lifetime I have had a certain underground reputation, though the professional music world has become closed off to me, one might say adamantly and on ideological grounds. Those are the possibilities. But past a certain age, recognition can aid only one’s vanity.





This article is brought to you by the author who owns the copyright to the text.

Should you want to support the author’s creative work you can use the PayPal “Donate” button below.

Your donation is a transaction between you and the author. The proceeds go directly to the author’s PayPal account in full less PayPal’s commission.

Facts & Arts neither receives information about you, nor of your donation, nor does Facts & Arts receive a commission.

Facts & Arts does not pay the author, nor takes paid by the author, for the posting of the author's material on Facts & Arts. Facts & Arts finances its operations by selling advertising space.



Browse articles by author

More Music Reviews

Nov 13th 2022
EXTRACTS: "Classical guitarist Jose Manuel Lezcano breaks new ground with his first solo CD,  “Homage: Spain & Latin America”. He combines two Scarlatti sonatas and his adaptation of works by Maurice Ravel, Bill Evans and the great Paraguayan guitar virtuoso Augustin Barrios. Mood and tempo jump from the contemplative to familiar classics to dance to jazz. I found the CD so captivating I played it in loop for hours." ----- "Twice a Grammy-awarded  composer and guitarist, Lezcano lives in retirement in the U.S. northeast and teaches at Keene State College in New Hampshire where he holds the title emeritus professor."
Sep 11th 2022
EXTRACT: "When I try to understand my life as a critic in the dazzling world of piano music, I am at a loss. We have inherited so much over 300 years that I feel overwhelmed. There is no obvious focal point. What is at the heart of piano world? -- Personally I could not make it through the day without the stimulation of piano performance. My home resounds with music all my waking hours, constantly renewed from the thousand-odd CDs I have accumulated." ----- Picture: The author, Michael Johnson.
Jun 21st 2022
EXTRACT: "This novel is nothing short of a Tolstoian epic.   Author Lawson, a true polymath, is up to the task. He is an accomplished pianist and composer, retired archdeacon of the Church of England and author of some 14 books." ---- "Rounding out his career, Lawson is also a trained psychotherapist who has worked with several pianists, including child prodigies." ----- "I know of no other writer who can draw on such a varied and pertinent background and weave them into a single tale."
Dec 18th 2021
EXTRACT: "......, I read all the time in Russian, French and English. Right now I’m finishing the new book of my favorite Russian author Ludmila Ulitzkaya. Of course, I have read most of classics to Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Bulgakov, Pushkin, Akhmatova. I think it’s important to read Russian literature to understand Russian music, to understand the suffering and the spirituality of the characters of Dostoevsky, Tolstoy and Bulgakov in order to feel the depth of Rachmaninov’s music. I also read a lot in French and English. For me, it’s important to go from contemporary writers to the classics and back."
Dec 9th 2021
EXTRACT: Q: "Your new CD is a turning point. Why is it so important to you?" ----- "A: It is all Brahms. I really wanted to do it this way. It is very important to me because it is my first solo CD. I’ve been spending a lot of my time working on Brahms, especially the Brahms Paganini Variations and the Handel Variations. I almost grew up with them. "
Dec 3rd 2021
EXTRACT: "A musical theatre legend has died. Stephen Sondheim, the greatest composer-lyricist of his generation, passed away on November 26 at the age of 91. His dramatic genius combined a rare blend of elements, that of an astonishingly versatile and sophisticated composer, and an incredibly witty wordsmith. His extraordinary output includes a staggering 16 musicals as composer and lyricist, a further three as lyricist alone, as well as four musical revues featuring compilations of hit songs from his shows."
Nov 27th 2021
EXTRACT: "Most important  to him, he explained, is maintaining his individuality in interpretation. He feels it was a mistake in his past to pick and choose bits from different teachers and combine them into a finished performance. He has decided to create his own perspective, and 'go for it'."
Oct 28th 2021
EXTRACTS: "The 16th International Beethoven Piano Competition came to a rousing climax in Vienna on 21 October with first prizewinner Aris Alexander Blettenberg’s lyrical rendering of the Beethoven Piano Concerto No 1." ---- "The other two finalists, Austrian Philipp Scheucher and South Korean Dasol Kim, played Beethoven’s Fourth and Fifth Concertos respectively."
Sep 21st 2021
EXTRACT: "Top prize, worth 22,000 euros, went to Jae Hong Park, a flamboyant, emotive player with and a firm grasp of Rachmaninov, and second prize went to Do-Hyun Kim, who played Prokofiev’s second concerto with some considerable verve. Placing third was Lukas Sternath, a young Austrian who performed Beethoven’s Fifth Piano Concerto with cool charm -- the opposite of Park’s style."
Jul 9th 2021
EXTRACT: " .....I have to give everything in these concerts,.... "
Jun 26th 2021
EXTRACT: What do you want to be known as? --- As “Stewart Goodyear, composer and pianist”.
Mar 15th 2021
EXTRACT: Denis Pascal, founder of the French Trio Pascal: ".....recording studios began working again. We recorded our Schubert trios at the end of September. And musicians everywhere are finding that the crisis allows time for a certain introspection and questioning into the way music is performed. Music will play a much more important role after the crisis."
Feb 12th 2021
EXTRACTS: "She began her piano training rather late in life – age 8." ..... "I want to contribute a sense of joy by discovering atypical works that might surprise an educated public. I have great experience and am inclined to share them with anyone who can appreciate them, or as André Gide wrote, anyone “who has an open mind”."
Jan 31st 2021
EXTRACTS: "A new recording of Franz Liszt’s piano compositions presents ten carefully balanced pieces in a double-CD album aptly titled Between Light and Darkness, launched by Piano Classics. The pianist, the veteran French virtuoso Vincent Larderet .... Larderet opens his CD with a moving exploration of Après une Lecture de Dante with a tortured lyricism unmatched by many of his contemporaries who play it. I was stunned the first time I heard his performance. In our interview below, he describes lyricism as “an essential facet of my musical conception. The piano must be able to sing like the human voice.” "
Jan 16th 2021
EXTRACT: "Jack Kohl is an American pianist and writer with three novels and two essay collections to his credit. His new collection, From the Windows of Diligence: Essays from a Standing Pianist, has drawn critical acclaim in the U.S. and Europe. In these reflections, he examines the power of ‘hack pianism’, the metaphor of running vs. the piano, and the ‘hidden gift’ of the Covid virus pandemic on solitary practicing. Robert Beattie spoke to Kohl about his music training and how he made the transition from pianist to author. (This edited interview was first published on www.Seenandheard-international.com and is reproduced with permission.)"
Dec 17th 2020
EXTRACT: "Freedom in Beethoven’s music takes many, frequently overlapping forms. There is heroic freedom in the Eroica (1803), freedom from political oppression in the Egmont Overture (1810), artistic freedom and innovation in the Ninth Symphony (1824). Today, Beethoven’s music remains deeply connected with a true humanism, which has the principles of freedom and self-determination at its heart. The composer’s music grew out of the age of European Enlightenment, which located human reason and the self at the centre of knowledge......"
Nov 27th 2020
EXTRACT: "One of the most durable tales in Western civilization – the legend of Faust – is brilliantly rendered in a piano adaptation, performed this week by the multi-talented Australian musician of German/Slovenian parentage, Ashley Hribar. A new recording of the music, now available digitally, will appear as a CD in the New Year. Hribar calls his recording, “Faust: A Mortal’s Tale”.  It is a personal musical reflection on the Faust story, loosely based on the 1926 silent film by Wilhelm Friedrich Murnau."
Aug 6th 2020
EXTRACT: "For 60 minutes, my mind was clear, the air was clean and the sound heavenly. It was my honor and privilege to have been there."
Jul 25th 2020
EXTRACT: "Scarlatti sonatas are enjoying a popular surge in recent years, tempting pianists –Europeans, Americans, Asians -- to try to master their broad range. Margherita has some advice: “Don’t be afraid to slow down, to speed up, to play the truly singable melodies with a quasi-Romantic feeling.” "